Okay. I was wrong about Ashton Jones. Thursday night’s “Tribute to Their Idol” was a test whether contestants can show their unique talent through a song of their idol and yet most contenders fall below expectations. It was not a good night performance wise.
Ashton Jones can’t sing and I was disappointed with all the flats and sharps. She had to go. (Status: OUT)
TOP 12
Karen Rodriguez. Her Selena and Jennifer Lopez inspired outfit looks great but her voice was not great it was bad. It was obvious from the start that she can’t hit the notes perfectly. I’m afraid that I am right about her. (Status: Don’t blame it on technical difficulty baby, what you mean you can’t hear? Or is it really just being tone deaf? Careful or you’re next to go.)
Thia Megia should know the song first, the writer, and the recording artist first and foremost to avoid humiliation in front of the world. She is a typical Filipino, who can hit the notes right but without personal style sings karaoke-like. (Status: Will make it to the top 10 for as long as the Filipino Americans vote for her.)
Haley Rheinhart’s style is disgustingly flirty which may in the end prove she has not much talent to share. (Status: You may end up in a lounge bar earning money by seducing your audience so pull your act together and battle the top 10.)
Pia Toscano did not even make it. Like Thia, Pia may do well in the karaoke singing contest. She falls way below Celine Dion. Great singers with perfect notes will think those half notes of hers are disturbing. I think she needs to rethink about singing diva-like, and instead develop her own style. (Status: May win the title if she can look better all throughout the contest, inspite of the fact that she obviously tries hard to outpitch Celine Dion but only made it halfway.)
Naima Adedapo surprised me with a good laugh. Her performance was a comic relief of one the most boring nights in American Idol 10. (Status: Keep the entertainment to last through the middle of the game.)
Jacob Lusk. He did not fly through his song. Though the arrangement was good, I think he should have practiced more. (Status: Will make it to the top 3.)
James Durbin. This attention grabbing contestant should know manners and stop mugging the camera from anyone and everyone including host Ryan Seacrest. He can sing through his idol’s song alright but I won’t waste my time on him. (Status: Will battle with Lusk on top 3 and literally wrestle with Seacrest for seconds worth of worldwide fame.)
Paul McDonald. I didn’t know the song he sang and neither did Jennifer Lopez, so there was no way of telling. (Status: Stop splurging your savings on a $4,500.00 suit. Regrets come later.)
Casey Abrams. He can never be Joe Cocker but I have no problem with his performance. I hope he fixes his stomach so he can get through the American Idol finals. And please surprise us more with something different. (Status: Will make it to the finals.)
Stefano Langone. I love the arrangement of Stevie Wonder’s “Lately”. I thought he was too ambitious to pick the song but I was wrong. He gave me something wonderful and interesting that night. (Status: If he connects to more viewers will make it to the top 5.)
Scotty Mc Creery is to the boys and Haley Rheinhart is to the girls. Nothing much, but charm and flirtiness that got him votes and the deep voice which tells his vocal range is as short as one octave. (Status: Maintain the coy and you’ll get to top 8.)
Boredom is kicking on me lately. I am getting to become uninterested with the contestant’s predictable style. The American Idol producer has to do something about it.
8.316943
124.685651